Night 3 / Day 4

Quote :

No one really caught that, I don't think, but I'll be watching for it from now on kufufufu.

Escaho and me took notes on it and mentioned it at the end of day 4, but that was erased :p

Luna wrote:

Honestly I don't think I would have killed the Cleric in that position, since the DK was working with the Town. Probably best to convert more. At the very least I would have witched Guardian to give Goremancer a vest or something like that, Guardian was already under threat of lynching if he gave vests to anyone else.

The Cleric had to die I think, because the death knight would still get healed as soon as the crypt opened. But yeah, manipulating Socretin or Guardian would've been best. Manipulating Nick because he might be the death knight (who was immune to manipulation) was fail.

Maybe they could've waited with killing Waaagh for one more night and then witch the bard on the death knight next. Either way, rule-derping from the bad guys killed this game.

Luna wrote:

Why have the keybearers not revealed and given them all to one player for warding? It's impossible for either Haunting member to have a key, all possible converts are dead and the only neutral left has become a Diviner.

CmG wants to give the keys to Ubernox so that if he's warded, the haunting can do nothing to stop the opening of the crypt unless they kill him (that means no conversions).

But Ubernox doesn't seem to get it.

Question:

DK kills roleblockers so could the banshee witch the paladin to smite the death knight which ends up roleblocking the deathknight which kills the paladin?

They should start killing keybearers because they then have to vote a new keybearer and can't get the key till the next day.
Kill + witch bard and/or paladin(if question I asked is true) onto death knight.
The town will still be looking for the assassin and stalling the crypt from being opened gives them time.

After the bard and paladin dies then they can start converting targets again. Better to use the assassin while they can and get as much confusion into the town as they can

NVM forgot paladin immune to witching

Not opening a new dead chat thread. I don't think it's necessary.

Yes, nobody got lynched. I bet you didn't see it coming, but Fragos is the Banshee!

ZOMGZ really?

We weren't aware of that ages ago, no sir not at all!

xD

Fragos is in a hilarious position, he can just troll the people who would get most annoyed by being converted; Kromos or Nick.

Admin wrote:

Maybe they could've waited with killing Waaagh for one more night and then witch the bard on the death knight next. Either way, rule-derping from the bad guys killed this game.

Try hosting it again? I'm not exactly happy about being killed night 2 as Diviner for being scum either lol. This game had so much potential in it. I'd be sad if it just ended like this.

I'm at least glad you didn't make any rule changes during the game, it's funny when a host thinks 'No, my custom scum roles are going to lose!' so they try to even the odds.

I hope you send my message to CmG, I want him to bitch and moan tomorrow in day chat and try to finish the game quickly.

The mechanics allowed for plenty of opportunities for scum, but they weren't really used to their advantage. Even now the Haunting is considering to convert someone who was already one of the assassin suspects and who has no way of proving himself. The reason? So that he gets lynched instead of the real assassin.

I don't see what they're seeking to gain from that.


@Sumikoko:
I might host a game with riddles again, but I'd either have to dumb down the other mechanics so anyone can play without double-checking the rules to make sure they understand the implications of the decisions they make or I'd have to be more picky in deciding who gets to play and who doesn't...

You won't believe how many times I facepalmed this game.

"Azeryuu is scum because he visited the culted executioner who died and if he is the lynch immune death knight who can win with the town we should totally lynch him on day 2 so that the Haunting will know who he is!"
"Azeryuu can't be the paladin because he didn't get a feedback message for a smite and Luna's name totally wasn't red or anything, so he couldn't have killed her!"
"I write -reveal key in day chat to prove that I have no key and actually believe it'll work!"
"I will claim Thief in my defense while the town has no better targets, because the town really won't mind giving me a key so I can kill one of their members at night."
"Guys! I got dominated last night. Wait, what? Oh yeah. I really didn't get culted because the paladin already smote yesterday and there weren't 2 kills last night or anything."
"I'm going to smite the claimed Cleric so he can't heal me tonight if he's telling the truth!"
"Let's witch the Death Knight so we have 2 kills at night!"
"Oh no! The Haunting might witch the paladin to smite the death knight so he'll die!"
"I want to give my key to CmG even though he hasn't revealed his keys in day chat."
"I write -reveal key in day chat to prove I have a key so that the other keybearer can give his keys to me. Nevermind that I have to PM this to the game master to make it work."

You're not going to catch up to my post count that easily, Mr. Admin

Damn, stop overtaking me!

End the night already, I wanna see what happens

Admin wrote:

@Sumikoko:
I might host a game with riddles again, but I'd either have to dumb down the other mechanics so anyone can play without double-checking the rules to make sure they understand the implications of the decisions they make or I'd have to be more picky in deciding who gets to play and who doesn't...

I lol'd at your facepalm moments.

Just a bit of food for thought. I know typically it's "fair" to random.org all the roles instead of picking who gets what role, so players don't accuse the host of being biased or whatever. But in a warped setup like this, it may be in your best interest, for a more interesting game, to handpick the leader roles. But who knows. :p

So they're thinking of converting Mopin...?

Hi I'm dead.

And it looks like I wasn't converted. Phew.

EDIT: And it looks like I shouldn't be posting in this thread, come to think of it. Oops.

MODKILL HIM

Man what a wasted opportunity for the Haunting to troll-convert someone

Derp DK probs killed you

So awesome, I wonder if a convert happened or was blocked?

I want some pitty points.
I was screwed from the beginning with my team mates.

but hey at least its over fast (for a cult game).
Day 5 and things should be under wraps..

I want some pity points, half the power roles in the game raped me on night 1, and my conversion got me immediately smited.

Looks like I'm the DK kill. Waiting to see if there'll be a converted (convertee?) suicide.

Welcome to the dead, wolfcheese. Nick is calling you lucky. How cruel!