Night 2 / Day 3

Welcome Sumikoko, the Diviner.

Roles & Deadlynches so far:
Luna - Executioner
Rocshi - Thief
Sumikoko - Diviner
Kromos - Acolyte (deadlynched day 2)

I no longer think Sumikoko should be deadlynched.

Call it a hunch.

Night is over :p

You have a day lynch now. 2 votes needed.

Bork I'm dead and participating in another game and even I'm wondering where the new day is, dawg xD

Takes a while to send all those PMs and write the RP :p

I wonder if the Haunting actually pulled off a successful convert tonight.

Apparently being a woman makes you a popular target in this game.

Curse you Sumi! Two back to back games where I was sure you were Mafia, you make a mockery of me.

Guardian seemed very sure that the Haunting tried to recruit, he states it as a fact... so is he a member of the Haunting or someone who didn't get a successful heal off last night?

This night was REALLY good for the haunting. It got even better with the last few action changes that were sent.

Sumikoko clearly hinted at her role on day 2 when she said that she wouldn't become very useful until later in the game. I don't think she was that scummy at all.

Fun fact: the death knight had 2 members of the haunting as his 3rd and 4th picks for kills (in the PM he sent me he motivated his choices)

You have to remember that I focused a lot on Socretin because I knew he was innocent. I therefore was biased against anyone who continued to prioritize the validity of his claim as a major talking point, hence my suspicion of Rocshi and Sumi. Taken by itself, the Goremancer/Azeryuu/Socretin circle isn't necessarily innocent, but the context of the way it played out makes it completely believable. Goremancer immediately throws Azeryuu under the bus, Azeryuu confirms his story. Azeryuu claims Paladin, before anyone even considered the possibility I was smitten, and Socretin attempts to clear him before everyone realises what actually happened. We have three major Town PRs all un-cc'ed that corroborated eachother's stories without knowing it at first.

Hence why I was one of the people that had my eye on Rocshi, Sumi and Drama because they were the three that prolonged the discussion. I thought that Drama was just needlessly trolling and insulting people at first, but since there was little else to go on I put my tentative scum-pin on them. Of course, like I said this was in the knowledge that Socretin was 100% Exorcist. When will people learn to trust my last wills, dear me...

Hmm Sumi Rocshi who do you think we should deadlynch?

I have a slight suspicion that Guardian was converted last night (pretty darn certain Socretin would have been the one warded).

I'd prefer to deadlynch people to reveal roles and not necessarily current alignments though. I think Guardian may have something to hide. Maybe Nick could be a good deadlynch target, I like knowing the roles of people who talk a lot in day chat it lets you see their thought process as they discuss the day.

Yeah, I understand your point of view. But I don't understand why nobody even tried to get some suspicion off sumikoko. Afraid to be thought of as fellow haunting players perhaps?

Don't think either of them has been online yet... No posts from Sumikoko in Zack's thread either.

I think it was difficult because the conversation kept being looped back to Socretin. If you don't have any hard evidence on day 1 it's quite a commitment to try and save someone who you think is a bit scummy. That's why people rely on the pressure vote. Okay in a setup like this I still can't quite believe the sequence of events that led up to so many claims, but if someone has contributed his opinions a lot in day chat and you're aware that a lot of other people think he's also suspicious then sometimes you can't resist pressuring for a role-claim.

It's just a shame that Rocshi happened to be a neutral which no one wanted to leave alive. Unlike the Black Wizard who can survive for most of the game mwahaha.

He should never have claimed Thief. Acolyte or Stalker perhaps. Maybe even Survivor (if he wanted to gamble that the DK wouldn't just keep attacking him)

Thief can be inconvenient for both sides.

Goremancer

Did Goremancer just claim Witched?

What a fool! I guess we'll be seeing him in dead tonight then when he gets lynched.

He really doesn't read the rules does he?

So my suspicions were right he was converted.

So much fail. The Haunting recruits a confirmed TPR, who outs himself while trolling.

So far the town hasn't responded to his claim. Maybe none of them read the rules

Uh apparently many Townspeople also did not read the rules thoroughly.

Bork put me back in the game, I may have been converted but I can't let such a mistake slide! I can't think of any good reason why someone would report Witched, it's gamethrowing by accident, there's no reason to fake it either.

Unless he is jester...

So many jesters this game.

Hehe.. and now he refers to his own wall on the other SFM.

Goremancer must be drunk. There is no other explanation.

AND HE QUOTES THE PM SO EVERYONE CAN SEE HE WAS CONVERTED.

MVP right there.

Almost as good as when he quoted and coloured the rule saying that the Paladin wouldn't be informed of his results until the next night as proof that Azeryuu wasn't the Paladin.

I don't believe he is a Jester, it might be a good jester type ploy but like I said Socretin confirms Azeryuu as Town, Azeryuu confirms Goremancer.

Rofl

I wasn't even referring to that play I was just calling him an idiot, time to delete that post because other players may now infer something from it

If he guessed correctly by accident, he would need to appear as scum now and this is a perfect way to do it.

Ah, so there was a man with a plan after all.